Power Play: Compound Vs Recurve

The compound bow and the recurve bow are two of the most popular bows on the market. But which is more powerful?

The recurve bow is a type of traditional bow that dates back thousands of years. It is curved so that it can store more energy, resulting in more powerful shots. On the other hand, compound bows have a mechanical system of cables, cams, pullers, and other moving parts that work together to create a powerful bow.

The maximum draw weight for a recurve bow is around 70 pounds, while compound bows can go up to 80 pounds. Compound bows also have a let-off feature, which means that if you have a bow with an 80-pound draw weight and 90% let-off, you will only be holding 8 pounds of weight at full draw. This makes compound bows more popular among hunters and competitive archers as they can hold the bow longer at full draw and place more accurate shots.

While recurve bows require more upper body strength and practice to master, they tend to be lighter and easier to carry, which can be an advantage during a hunt. Compound bows, on the other hand, require less strength and are more accurate and powerful, allowing for greater distance from the target.

Compound bows are more powerful due to their mechanical systems

A compound bow's power is enhanced by its mechanical systems, which include a lot of cables, cams, pullers, and other moving parts. These work together to create a powerful bow that can project arrows with speed and force. The pulley system of a compound bow means that less upper body strength is required to use it, making it more powerful than a recurve bow.

The cams of a compound bow are found at the end of the limbs and, along with the extra strings and cables, are the most notable difference between a compound and a traditional bow. The cams give an added mechanical advantage, allowing the shooter to pull more draw weight than with a recurve bow. The shooter still has to pull that heavy weight back, but they get more performance for equal effort.

The cams of a compound bow provide 'let-off', meaning that when the shooter pulls the string beyond the peak draw weight, the cams make it easier to keep pulling the string. This also makes it much easier to hold. For example, if you’re shooting a 70-pound compound bow, you might only be holding back 15 pounds once you are at full draw. Whereas with a 70-pound recurve or longbow, you’ll be holding all 70 pounds at full draw.

The shooter must put all the energy into the limbs by drawing the bow, but the cams and more efficient design give an added mechanical advantage. At a certain point in the draw cycle, the cams provide 'let-off', making it much easier to hold back. This is the primary advantage of compounds, making it much easier to hold longer at full draw and aim more precisely.

The overall design of a compound bow is more efficient, putting more of the imparted energy into the arrow as it is released. This efficiency and mechanical advantage allow them to impart much more energy into an arrow than an equivalent draw-weight traditional bow. The same arrow will be shot much faster out of a modern compound than a modern traditional bow of the same draw weight.

Recurve bows are lighter and easier to carry

Recurve bows are also cheaper than compound bows, and easier to maintain and fix. If a string snaps, a recurve bow can be re-strung by hand, whereas a compound bow would be difficult to use in the field. Recurve bows are also easier to assemble, whereas compound bows are built to stay assembled and are more technical to transport.

Recurve bows are also the only type of bow currently allowed in the Olympic Games. They are also the type of bow that beginners are taught to use.

Recurve bows require more upper body strength to draw and hold

When it comes to upper body strength, recurve bows require more effort to draw and hold than compound bows. This is because recurve bows rely entirely on the archer's strength, without the benefit of mechanical assistance. The design of a recurve bow means that the farther you draw the bowstring, the heavier the draw weight becomes, and it never lets off. For example, an archer shooting a 50-pound recurve bow holds all 50 pounds at full draw. This demands significant upper body strength and can be challenging, especially for beginners or those with less physical strength.

In contrast, compound bows utilise a system of pulleys and cables, or cams, that provide mechanical advantage and reduce the amount of force needed to hold the bowstring once at full draw. This "let-off" feature makes it easier for the archer to aim and shoot with greater accuracy. For instance, a 70-pound compound bow with a 50% let-off will only require the archer to hold back 35 pounds of force when aiming. This reduced weight allows for better stability and improved accuracy.

The difference in required upper body strength between recurve and compound bows is further highlighted when considering their use in hunting. Recurve bows typically have lower draw weights and require the archer to be closer to their target. This demands not only physical strength but also technique and experience. Compound bows, on the other hand, offer more power and accuracy from a greater distance, making skills like stealth and concealment less critical.

Additionally, the let-off feature of compound bows makes them more suitable for hunting scenarios where one might need to wait hidden and stationary for an extended period before taking a shot. The reduced weight at full draw allows hunters to hold their bow at full draw for longer periods without experiencing as much fatigue.

While recurve bows demand more upper body strength, they also offer certain advantages. Their simpler design and lack of mechanical parts make them lighter in weight and easier to carry, transport, and maintain. Recurve bows are also preferred by traditional archers who value the connection to nature and the craftsmanship and mastery required to shoot accurately without mechanical assistance.

Compound bows require less strength and are more accurate

When it comes to archery, power is essential. It gives arrows speed and distance, allowing them to reach their target with force. While both compound and recurve bows are powerful, compound bows are generally more powerful. However, compound bows require less strength and are more accurate, making them a popular choice for archers.

A compound bow's power comes from its mechanical systems, which include cables, cams, pullers, and other moving parts. This design gives compound bows an advantage over recurve bows in terms of power and speed. The pulley system of a compound bow reduces the amount of upper body strength needed to use it, making it more accessible to a wider range of people. The "let-off" feature further reduces the force required to hold the bow at full draw, with modern compounds offering up to 90% let-off. This means that an archer only needs to hold a small percentage of the bow's peak draw weight, making it easier to aim and reducing the amount of strength needed.

In contrast, recurve bows rely entirely on the archer's strength. A recurve bow with a 70-pound draw weight requires the archer to hold back all 70 pounds of force when aiming, which can be challenging for some. The lack of mechanical assistance in a recurve bow means that the archer's strength and technique play a more significant role in achieving accurate shots.

The design of a compound bow also contributes to its accuracy. The cams or wheels reduce the bow's draw weight during the draw cycle, making it easier to aim. Additionally, compound bows have defined draw stops, ensuring that the power stroke is consistent for each shot. The use of mechanical release aids or triggers further enhances the accuracy of compound bows, allowing for precise and identical arrow releases.

While recurve bows may be more challenging to master due to the lack of mechanical assistance, they offer a traditional and minimalist experience that some archers prefer. Recurve bows are also generally lighter and easier to carry, making them advantageous in certain hunting situations. However, they require more practice and technique to achieve the same level of accuracy as compound bows.

In summary, compound bows require less strength and are more accurate due to their mechanical systems and design features. Recurve bows, on the other hand, offer a traditional experience and have their own advantages in terms of weight and portability. The choice between a compound and recurve bow ultimately depends on the archer's preferences, experience level, and intended use.

Recurve bows are more traditional and simpler in design

Recurve bows are defined by their distinctive hook at the end of their limbs, with the string resting on a portion of the belly of the limb. The limbs curve towards the archer near the riser but away from them at the ends or tips. This curve is known as a recurve and can store and provide more power to an arrow than a simple longbow of the same size.

The simplicity of the recurve bow is also reflected in its use. Recurve bows are typically shot without any sights by pulling the string back with your fingers. This requires a great deal of practice and technique. Recurve bows are also lighter and easier to carry, which can be a serious advantage when hunting. They are also cheaper, easier to maintain, and easier to fix.

Recurve bows are also more stylish. They are favoured by archers who want a back-to-the-roots experience and see their bows as an extension of their bodies.

Frequently asked questions