Boat Ownership: Shareholder Protection And Corporate Benefits

There are several reasons why an individual or business may want to transfer boat ownership to an LLC or corporation. One of the main reasons is liability protection, as the corporation acts as a liability shield. This means that if someone is injured or killed on the boat, they can sue the corporation that owns the boat, and the personal assets of the shareholders are protected. Another reason is tax savings, as the purchase of an entity such as an LLC is typically not subject to sales or use tax. Additionally, corporate ownership can provide privacy, as the name of the owner of a boat is readily available to the public, while some states, such as Delaware, do not include the names of a corporation's directors or officers in the public record.

Liability protection

However, this protection is not absolute and there are certain exceptions. For example, if a shareholder signs a personal guarantee for a company loan, they can be held personally liable if the company defaults on repayment. Similarly, if a shareholder acts as a director or officer of the company, they can be held personally liable for company debts in certain situations, such as continuing to trade despite knowing the company is insolvent or disposing of company assets for free or below market value.

In some cases, a plaintiff may be able to "pierce the corporate veil" and hold shareholders personally liable for the corporation's debts or liabilities. This can occur if the shareholder exercises complete domination over the corporation and uses it to commit fraud or if corporate formalities are disregarded to the point where there is little distinction between the corporation's and shareholder's affairs.

It is important to note that the liability protection provided by a corporation or LLC for a boat is generally intended for maritime businesses, such as a charter boat operation, rather than for recreational boat owners. In the case of recreational boat ownership, the liability protection may be disregarded, and shareholders may be forced to defend lawsuits themselves.

To summarize, while owning a boat through a corporation or LLC can provide liability protection, it is not a guarantee. Shareholders may still be held personally liable in certain circumstances, and it is important for them to understand the limitations and exceptions to this protection.

Tax savings

Owning a boat through a corporation or LLC can provide some tax savings, although the benefits are limited and depend on the specific circumstances and location. Here are some key points to consider:

• Depreciation: Boat owners can use IRS Section 179 to deduct the cost of a boat as an expense rather than depreciating it over time. This strategy is intended to help small businesses acquire essential equipment.
• Secondary Residence: If a boat has a berth, a galley, and a toilet, it may qualify for a mortgage interest deduction as a second home. However, this strategy has limitations, and professional advice is recommended.
• Business Expenses: Operating a boat as a business allows for various deductions such as boat insurance, slip fees, loan interest, and repairs. This strategy is known as "active yacht ownership."
• LLC Ownership: Purchasing an LLC that owns a boat can help buyers avoid sales or use taxes in some states, such as California. This is because the purchase of a business entity is typically exempt from such taxes.
• Fractional Membership: Boat owners can lease usage slots to members, generating income while retaining exclusive ownership. This can lead to tax benefits, especially if the boat is used for personal and rental purposes.
• Charter Business: If a boat is used for an existing or new charter business, it may be eligible for tax benefits associated with a trade or business. However, this strategy has complex rules and requirements that must be met.

Considerations and Complexities

It's important to note that the tax benefits of corporate or LLC ownership of a boat are generally modest and may not apply in all cases. Some key complexities to consider:

• Limited Benefits: In certain locations, such as California, corporate or LLC ownership may have minimal impact on sales tax or annual property tax assessments.
• Liability Protection: While corporate or LLC ownership can provide liability protection for maritime businesses, it may not offer the same level of protection for recreational boat owners.
• Complex Requirements: Strategies like the fractional membership program and charter business have complex rules and requirements. Seeking professional tax and legal advice is essential to navigate these complexities.
• Tax Reform Impact: Recent tax reforms have affected strategies such as the vacation rental scenario and trade or business classification, impacting depreciation and loss offset rules.
• Recapture Tax: Depreciating a boat's value and offsetting other income can trigger a recapture tax liability upon the future sale of the boat. This can result in significant tax obligations.
• Net Operating Loss Limitations: Recent tax reforms have introduced limitations on net operating losses, which can impact the tax benefits of certain strategies.

In conclusion, while there are potential tax savings when a boat is owned by a corporation or LLC, it is a complex area with varying benefits depending on the specific circumstances and location. Seeking professional advice is crucial to navigate the intricacies and optimize tax strategies.

Privacy

The Coast Guard maintains a database of American-flagged vessels, and the name of the owner of any boat is readily available on the Internet. This means that anyone can look up who owns a particular boat. However, if a boat is owned by a corporation, only the name of the corporation is made public, and the personal information of the individual owners (i.e., the corporation's directors or officers) is not disclosed. This level of privacy may be particularly attractive to celebrities and other owners of high-end boats.

It is important to note that this privacy protection is not absolute. In certain legal situations, the "corporate veil" can be "pierced," meaning that a plaintiff's attorney may be able to pursue the shareholders personally, as if the corporation did not exist. This typically occurs when a corporation is deemed to have no legitimate business purpose and exists solely to hold ownership of a recreational vessel. Therefore, while corporate ownership of a boat can provide some privacy protection for shareholders, it is not a foolproof solution.

Tax exemption

In the context of boat ownership, tax exemption can refer to several strategies that boat owners may employ to reduce their tax liability. One approach is to form a corporation or Limited Liability Company (LLC) that owns the boat instead of owning it directly. This strategy may provide certain tax advantages, but it is important to note that the overall effectiveness depends on various factors, including the owner's state of residence and the boat's intended use.

One of the primary tax benefits of corporate or LLC ownership is the potential exemption from sales or use tax. In some states like California, purchasing a corporation or LLC that owns a boat is not subject to sales or use tax because it is considered the purchase of a business entity rather than the boat itself. This can result in significant tax savings, especially for high-value boats. However, it is crucial to consult with legal and tax professionals, as this strategy may not apply in all states, and there can be complex logistical and administrative considerations.

Another tax advantage of corporate or LLC ownership is liability protection, which can shield the boat owner's personal assets in the event of a lawsuit. This protection is particularly relevant if the boat is used for charter or commercial purposes. Additionally, corporate or LLC ownership can provide privacy for the boat owner, as the public records in some states only disclose the name of the corporation, not the individual owner.

It is worth noting that forming a corporation or LLC for boat ownership may not offer significant tax benefits for recreational boat owners in certain states. For example, in California, corporate or LLC ownership typically has minimal impact on sales tax, personal property tax, or income tax assessments. Moreover, foreign registry of a recreational boat in California may provide little to no tax benefit and could introduce additional complexities.

In summary, while tax exemption strategies like corporate or LLC ownership can provide benefits, they should be carefully evaluated with the help of legal and tax professionals. The effectiveness of these strategies depends on various factors, including the owner's state of residence, the boat's intended use, and the specific tax regulations in the applicable jurisdiction.

Legitimate business purpose

If a corporation or an LLC owns a boat, it must have a legitimate business purpose if it is to protect the owners from personal liability. This is because the liability shields provided by limited liability companies were designed to protect businesses and not private individuals. Therefore, courts can "pierce the corporate veil" and hold the members of a limited liability company personally liable if they determine that the company serves no legitimate business purpose.

For example, if a boat is owned by a limited liability company, liability for incidents involving the vessel will flow to the company itself, instead of its members. When a vessel held by a limited liability company is involved in an accident that leads to litigation, an injured party would need to sue the limited liability company that holds the vessel. The limited liability company members' personal assets are shielded from creditors of the limited liability company and, conversely, the limited liability company’s assets (usually the vessel) are shielded from creditors of the owner.

However, if a boat is the company’s sole asset and the company has no business purpose, a plaintiff’s attorney may be able to pierce the corporate veil and pursue the members personally as if the business entity did not exist. Therefore, it is important to ensure that a limited liability company is operated in every respect as a separate entity from the owner. This means taking steps to ensure that the limited liability company’s accounts and a member’s personal accounts are not used interchangeably. For example, a member should never use limited liability company funds to pay for personal expenses.

In addition, if assets are transferred to a limited liability company after the owner of those assets has a creditor, a court could construe this as a "fraudulent transfer", intended only to shield assets from creditors. If a court determines that a transfer was fraudulent and intended only to shield assets from existing creditors, the court can allow creditors to recover those assets.

To avoid this, a legitimate business purpose for the company must exist, and the company must be properly structured. This means that the limited liability company must be correctly operated and administered, and the members must treat it as its own legal entity. This will make it very difficult for a court to pierce the corporate veil, even if a litigant is willing to undergo the costly and time-consuming process of attempting to do so.

Frequently asked questions